Showing posts with label amitabha bagchi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label amitabha bagchi. Show all posts

Saturday, 22 December 2012

Above Average by Amitabha Bagchi

Novembers book group meeting was at Susie's house and we discussed 'Above Average'.  It was set in modern day India and followed the life of a middle-class student from school through to PhD in America.

We didn't like this book, we found it lacking in plot, full of cultural references to India which I'm sure would be funny if you were local to where the book was set but they went right over our heads.  We didn't really care about the characters and found it a struggle to finish the book and when we did we were disappointed by the ending, if you can call it that.  The only thing we thought had promise was the idea of writing a modern novel about the normal people in India, we've all heard of the poor and super rich and we were interested to hear about the average people.

Concept: 5/10
Plot: 3/10
Ending: 1/10
Cover: 2/10
Page Turner: 0/10
Who to slap: The Author
Where's the cheese: The uncomfortable passages where he read out his poetry about his girlfriend and her dark nipples.

Overall: 2/10

We chose our next book from the following:

  • North and South by John Jakes
  • The End of Mr Y by Scarlett Thomas
  • House of Riverton by Kate Morgan
  • The Lies of Loche Lamora by Scott Lynch
  • Princess Bride by William Goldman
We chose 'The End of Mr Y' by Scarlett Thomas which we will be reading for our January meeting.

Monday, 17 September 2012

There But For The by Ali Smith

We were back at our old haunt, The Warwick, for Rachel's leaving do.  Lovely food as always and we even remembered to talk a bit about the book ... which was nice :-)

I think, overall, we were quite disappointed by this book.  The blurb on the back set quite an interesting concept and we were looking forwards to finding out why Miles shut himself in a strangers bedroom during a dinner party.  We wanted to learn more about his thought processes and how all the people featured in the book fitted together.  Instead we were faced with incredibly long chapters (the book has only five) and long, rambling, seemingly non-linear narratives which made it difficult to read in short bursts.  Or rather, difficult to remember what you've read in the last session and link it to what you're reading now.  The ending was also unsatisfactory, leaving us with lots of questions about Miles and every other character in this random book.

Concept: 7/10
Plot: 2/10
Ending: 0/10
Cover: 1/10
Page Turner: 1/10
Slap: The woman who owned the house and profited from Miles' stunt whilst losing her husband and mind in the process.

Overall: 2/10

We chose our next book from the following:
  • Bel Canto by Ann Patchett
  • Above Average by Amitabha Bagchi
  • Street Freak by Jared Dillan
  • The Elegance of the Hedgehog by Muriel Barbery
  • The Wicked Girls by Alex Marwood
  • The Garden of Evening Mists by Tan Twan Eng
We chose 'Above Average' by Amitabha Bagchi which we will be reading for the November meeting.

Our next meeting will be at Kate's house, 8pm on Wed 10th October.  Please bring along a book review based on the theme 'Christmas Lunch' as we will be choosing the book we'll be reading for the December meeting.